Welcome to LinuxMedNews
 up a level
 post article
 search
 admin
 main
 parent
 thread


Why you're not required to return the favor
by Max Hyre on Friday December 01, @08:26AM

In the article, you pointed to a GNU tract on free software. In it, we find:

You should also have the freedom to make modifications and use them privately in your own work or play, without even mentioning that they exist.

In support of this freedom, the GPL puts no requirement on you to redistribute your modifications. In Section 2, your are told you may ``modify your copy [...], and copy and distribute....'' under conditions a), b), and c). a) and c) make no mention of you redistributing the program.

The rub comes in condition b), wherein you are required to

cause any work [...] that [...] is derived from the Program [...], to be licensed as a whole [...] under the terms of this License.
This is a reasonable condensation of condition b), except for the first ellipsis. What I left out were the words emphasized here: ``any work that you distribute or publish''.

Condition b) only applies to you if you ``distribute or publish'' the (possibly modified) work. It in no way requires you to distribute or publish.

Thus, we see that the GPL indeed gives you the freedom quoted above, to modify the program and use it personally without passing on the changes. The GPL has no interest in prying into the contents of your hard disk, it just says if you pass this on with changes, then the changes must be distributed with the same freedoms as the original. Hence akihabara's entirely-valid remonstration. The GPL allows you to use the software without returning the favor, so long as you're only using, and not distributing, it.

Post Reply

Name
Email
Notify Notify me via email of responses to this message
Title
Comment
(Check those URLs! Don't forget the http://!)
Encoding
If none of the above mean anything to you, select 'Plain'!
Attachment
(You can attach a file to your reply which can then be retrieved by other readers.
Try to keep the file sizes below 500Kb in order to conserve network and server resources.)

Enter the above code (*Required)
Allowed HTML <B> <I> <P> <A> <LI> <OL> <UL> <EM> <BR> <TT> <HR> <STRONG> <BLOCKQUOTE> <DIV .*> <DIV> <P .*>
Important Stuff:
  • Note: Fields with bold titles are required.
  • Please try to keep posts on topic.
  • Try to reply to other people comments instead of starting new threads,
  • Read other people's messages before posting your own to avoid simply duplicating what has already been said.
  • Use a clear subject that describes what your message is about.
  • Please do not post offtopic, inflammatory, inappropriate, illegal, or offensive comments. Repeat offenders will be sanctioned.

  •  
    Google
     
    www.linuxmednews.com Web
    Advertisement: CCHIT certified EMR and Medical Practice Management Software from Medical Software Associates makes patient management easy. Free practice management and medical billing software demo available.
    All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest ©2000-2006 Ignacio Valdes, MD, MS.